Judgment calls: principle and politics in constitutional law

Book Cover
Average Rating
Oxford University Press,
Pub. Date:
Judgement Calls tackles one of the most important and controversial legal questions in contemporary America: How should judges interpret the Constitution? Our Constitution contains a great deal of language that is vague, broad, or ambiguous, making its meaning uncertain. Many people believe this uncertainty allows judges too much discretion. They suggest that constitutional adjudication is just politics in disguise, and that judges are legislators in robes who read the Constitution in accordance with their own political views. Some think that political decision making by judges is inevitable, and others think it can be restrained by "strict constructionist" theories like textualism or originalism. But at bottom, both sorts of thinkers believe that judging has to be either tightly constrained and inflexible or purely political and unfettered: There is, they argue, no middle ground.Farber and Sherry disagree, and in this book they describe and defend that middle ground. They show how judging can be--and often is--both principled and flexible. In other words, they attempt to reconcile the democratic rule of law with the recognition that judges have discretion. They explain how judicial discretion can be exercised responsibly, describe the existing constraints that guide and cabin such discretion, and suggest improvements.In exploring how constitutional adjudication works in practice (and how it can be made better), Farber and Sherry cover a wide range of topics that are relevant to their thesis and also independently important, including judicial opinion-writing, the use of precedent, the judicial selection process, the structure of the American judiciary, and the nature of legal education. They conclude with a careful look at how the Supreme Court has treated three of the most significant and sensitive constitutional issues: terrorism, abortion, and affirmative action. Timely, trenchant, and carefully argued,Judgment Calls is a welcome addition to the literature on the intersection of constitutional interpretation and American politics.
More Details
Also in this Series
More Like This
Reviews from GoodReads
Loading GoodReads Reviews.
Staff View

Grouping Information

Grouped Work ID ef5a0b85-6a8e-e743-da5f-83ea30d4c0e3
full_title judgment calls principle and politics in constitutional law
author farber daniel a
grouping_category book
lastUpdate 2017-08-14 05:04:51AM

Solr Details

_version_ 1579048661954854912
accelerated_reader_point_value 0
accelerated_reader_reading_level 0
author Farber, Daniel A., 1950-
author-letter Farber, Daniel A.,
author2 NetLibrary, Inc.
author2-role NetLibrary, Inc.
author_additional Daniel A. Farber and Suzanna Sherry.
author_display Farber, Daniel A
availability_toggle_arlington Available Now, Available Online, Entire Collection
callnumber-a KF8840
callnumber-first K - Law
callnumber-subject KF - United States
days_since_added 2819
detailed_location_arlington EBSCOhost
econtent_protection_type_arlington external
econtent_source_arlington EBSCOhost
format_arlington eBook
format_boost 10
format_category_arlington eBook
grouping_category book
id ef5a0b85-6a8e-e743-da5f-83ea30d4c0e3
isbn 9780199707812
item_details external_econtent:ils:.b13230505||EBSCOhost|Online|eBook|eBook|1|false|true|EBSCOhost||http://www.netlibrary.com.library.access.arlingtonva.us/urlapi.asp?action=summary&v=1&bookid=242298||Available Online||q||
itype_arlington eCollection
language English
language_boost 10
language_boost_es 1
lexile_score -1
lib_boost_arlington 50
literary_form Other
literary_form_full Other
local_callnumber_arlington Online
local_callnumber_exact_arlington Online
local_callnumber_left_arlington Online
local_days_since_added_arlington 2819
num_holdings 0
oclc (OCoLC)271657306
owning_library_arlington Arlington Public Library Online, Aurora Hills Online, Central Online, Cherrydale Online, Columbia Pike Online, Connection Crystal City Online, Detention Center Online, Glencarlyn Online, Local History Online, Plaza Online, Shirlington Online, Westover Online
physical xv, 201 p. ; 24 cm.
popularity 0
primary_isbn 9780199707812
publishDate 2009
publishDateSort 2009
publisher Oxford University Press,
rating 2.5
rating_facet oneStar, twoStar
record_details external_econtent:ils:.b13230505|eBook|eBook||English|Oxford University Press,|2009.|xv, 201 p. ; 24 cm.
recordtype grouped_work
scope_has_related_records a, arlington, c, d, g, h, o, p, s, u, v, w
scoping_details_arlington external_econtent:ils:.b13230505||Available Online|Available Online|false|true|false|false|false|true||||
table_of_contents The inevitability of American judicial review -- The democracy worry -- How to think about discretion -- Reason and relevance -- The anatomy of judgment -- Respect for precedent -- Explaining precedent -- Deliberation and multiple decision-makers -- Transparency -- Incrementalism -- Professionalism and the selection process -- The role of the legal academy -- Terrorism -- Abortion -- Affirmative action.
target_audience Other
target_audience_full Other
title Judgment calls principle and politics in constitutional law
title_display Judgment calls principle and politics in constitutional law
title_full Judgment calls [electronic resource] : principle and politics in constitutional law / Daniel A. Farber and Suzanna Sherry
title_short Judgment calls
title_sort judgment calls principle and politics in constitutional law
title_sub principle and politics in constitutional law